Gordon MacRae: A Birthday Tribute to an Underrated Talent

Gordon MacRae will probably always be best known for his unforgettable role as Curly in Oklahoma! (1955). He was an incredibly handsome dark-haired man with a rich, strong baritone singing voice. His roles were usually those of the clean-cut boy-next-door. MacRae was born Albert Gordon MacRae in East Orange, New Jersey on March 12, 1921. When he was young he started participating in drama club and began learning how to play several musical instruments. During World War II, he served as a navigator in the United States Army Air Force. In 1942, Gordon made his Broadway debut in the show “Junior Miss”. By 1947, he was signed to a recording contract with Capitol Records when he was discovered by them. Starting in 1949, Gordon began starring in movie musicals. The first was Look for the Silver Lining, co-starring June Haver and Ray Bolger. In 1950, MacRae made the first of five successful musical films with co-star Doris Day- Tea for Two.


Since I was a little girl, Oklahoma! (1955) has been one of my favorite musicals. Starring Gordon MacRae and Shirley Jones, this film is set in turn-of-the-century Oklahoma territory. It tells the story of a cowboy named Curly (Gordon MacRae) and a farm girl, Laurey (Shirley Jones), two young adults who–despite being in love with each other–are too prideful and stubborn to admit it. It takes Curly awhile to finally win her over and to fight off Laurey and Aunt Eller’s ranch hand, Jud Fry (Rod Steiger), who is also romantically interested in Laurey–to a really creepy extent. The movie is led by a vivacious supporting cast including Gloria Grahame as Ado Annie, Eddie Albert as the smooth-talking peddler Ali Hakim, and Charlotte Greenwood as Aunt Eller. If you’re like me and you love old romantic musicals, I highly recommend watching Oklahoma! if you’ve never seen it. Gordon MacRae’s performance is one that I personally believe made him a true talented heartthrob. I’m not sure how long I’ve had a crush on Curly, but I suspect I have since I was a little girl. Every time I watch the movie there’s no doubt I love him. Every time I hear him sing “People Will Say We’re in Love” and  every time I watch him propose to Laurey, I get the “butterflies in my tummy” feeling. It must be true love.

Gordon and Shirley worked together again the next year for the second and last time in another Rodgers and Hammerstein musical- Carousel (1956). The tone is much different than in Oklahoma! but MacRae and Jones are wonderful together yet again. MacRae shines in his role.

* Side note: I’ve heard that there will be a showing of this Oklahoma at the TCM Film Festival this year–newly restored–which I’m sure will be fun to watch on the big screen. Unfortunately I will not be attending this year.

Gordon MacRae and Shirley Jones in Oklahoma! (courtesy of doctormacro.com)

Gordon MacRae and Shirley Jones in Oklahoma! (courtesy of doctormacro.com)

On Moonlight Bay

One of Gordon MacRae’s other films I want to highlight is called On Moonlight Bay (1951). This was the third film he made with Doris Day. The movie is set just before World War I in a small town in Indiana. MacRae plays William Sherman, an ambitious but money-loathing college student who lives across the street from tomboy teenager Marjorie Winfield (Doris Day). At the beginning of the movie, Marjorie only cares about baseball and doesn’t seem to even realize boys exist. This all changes when she meets William one day. When she realizes she may have feelings for William, Marjorie decides to ditch her baseball garb and opts to dress like a “proper” young lady. She even decides to take dancing lessons to impression William. There is a lot more that goes on in the movie, but I won’t give any more of it away for those who have not seen it. It’s worthwhile to mention that this movie has a great supporting cast. Perhaps my favorite screen father figure ever, Leon Ames, stars as the patriarch of the Winfield family. His character is very similar to the character he played in Meet Me in St. Louis (1944): stern, and at times moody; but completely lovable and really funny. Rosemary DeCamp plays Mrs. Winfield, Billy Gray plays young Westley Winfield (a hilarious performance given by Gray), and Mary Wickes plays the family’s wisecracking maid, Stella. For fellow fans of Meet Me in St. LouisOn Moonlight Bay is comparable to that film in several ways (Leon Ames portraying the family father in both films is just one). It may not be quite as great as the latter, but for a light romantic comedy musical, it’s fantastic. For someone like me, watching 90 minutes of that stuff is heavenly.

Gordon was married to his wife Sheila (who actually just passed away about one week ago) from 1941-1967 and they had four children: Meredith, Heather, Gar, and Robert Bruce MacRae. After they divorced, Gordon married Elizabeth Lamberti in ’67 and they had one child: Amanda. They were married until his death. MacRae’s later life was unfortunately not an entirely happy one. In the late 1950s and 1960s, he began drinking heavily and eventually became an alcoholic. He went on to receive help and by the 1970s recovered from his alcoholism and even began helping others who were dealing with their own struggles. When he sobered up, he continued to record music and appear on television. In 1982, he suffered a stroke but kept performing when his health would allow him to. In 1986, Gordon MacRae died at his home in Lincoln, Nebraska from pneumonia, which resulted from complications from cancer of the jaw and mouth. He was 64 years old.

I wish there were more people today who knew the name of Gordon MacRae because he deserves to be remembered for being a great actor and–in my opinion–one of the finest singers in Hollywood history and one of the handsomest leading actors during the Golden Age.

Happy birthday Gordon. I’ll always love you.


17 thoughts on “Gordon MacRae: A Birthday Tribute to an Underrated Talent

  1. Lisa says:

    What a beautiful tribute by Meredith. She needn’t be concerned about more people knowing who he was because he was all the things she said and will be remembered as so by the people who have the inside and those like myself that love researching Golden Era stars. And I imagine there are alot of us.

  2. Cathy Moore says:

    Gordon MacRae was a household name when I was growing up in Brooklyn, NY. The GM fan club & newsletter hailed from my Grandma’s house. My aunt was a co-founder & vice president of it so she got to know Gordon & Sheila as friends. Gordon sang at my aunt’s wedding & I was one excited flower girl to finally get to meet him & Sheila!!! It was amazing. He sang The Lord’s Prayer & Bless This House. Years later, I also got to meet Heather & Gar in NYC.
    I agree with you, Meredith! Gordon MacRae is a true legend & it would be nice to see or hear more about him in the present. I love him & his beautiful baritone voice & natural acting style. I love watching his movies & listening to his music.

    • MeredithRiggs says:

      How cool is that…Your comment gave me a good amount of excitement upon reading it. Thanks, Cathy, for sharing your wonderful memories of Gordon MacRae! Do you have a favorite movie of his?

  3. Karen says:

    I absolutely love Gordon MacRae and have since I was a little girl and saw “Carousel.” His voice is – in my opinion – one of the best in the business, plus he was so incredibly handsome. I’ve seen almost all of his films and my only criticism of the films he made with Doris Day is that they focused too much on her and her singing then they did on him. He was so much more talented than she. His performance as Curly was, in my childhood imagination, the perfect man. Ah youth. Thanks for this lovely page – it’s so nice to see nice things written about a shining star that burned out far too soon.

  4. Anne says:

    I am sitting with my 95 yo Mom watching Oklahoma.
    We have always been GM fans because my parents graduated from Nottngham HS in Syracuse NY with Gordy.
    Always fun memories for them🤗

  5. Trevor Bott says:

    Meredith, a fine tribute to a great artist. I wonder if you could perhaps help me with a song query ? I recently purchased a Readers Digest cd set of Gordon’s & one song I have never heard of before is Taji. I’ve googled it a number of times & I just come up against a brick wall. I wondered if it’s from a musical & when he recorded it. If you could shed any light on this song, I would be extremely grateful.

    • MeredithRiggs says:

      Hey, Trevor! Thanks so much for reading my tribute. I really appreciate your kind words. I did a search on that song as well and, like you, didn’t find any details on it. I’ll try to search some more and if I find out more info, I will get back to you. Sorry I can’t be of any help at the time being!

      • Trevor Bott says:

        Hi Meredith
        Thanks for trying, hope you can come up with something – it’s really beginning to bug me !


  6. Miho Sasaji says:

    Hello. I’m a Japanese fan of Gordy who got a crash on him only recently when I saw Tea for Two. His beautiful baritone voice is so amazing and he himself is irresistibly charming, especially when he smiles! And a few days ago I saw Oklahoma! for the first time and fell in love with him again! I’m glad to know that off screen Gordy was exactly like Curly, plain and down to earth, according to Shirley Jones.
    I’m also a fan of old jazz singers including Doris Day, so it’s really a joy for me to see the movies of Gordy and Doris because you can enjoy two great singers singing many standard songs.
    It’s a real pity that not so many people remember him now. But I’m relieved now to find out there are ones who love Gordy here!

  7. Abigail Prohaska says:

    I was so happy to read your tribute.- I can assure you there are two people from Manchester England who have appreciated – loved – Gordon MacRae all our lives – my sister and myself. He was an incredibly expressive singer with a peerless emotional timbre and technique; no one has ever got near his standard in the great Rodgers and Hammerstein classics. And such a beauty. We’ll be ever grateful for his films and records!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s